Shonda Rhimes has got me by the throat - again!
How to Get Away with Murder, Season 1.
Honestly, the only thing that has truly preoccupied my brain for the last two weeks is who killed Lila.
Yes, I'm late to the party but as a writer, I cannot help but admire Shonda Rhimes ability hook us in, over and over again.
Grey's Anatomy. Scandal. Bridgerton. And now How to Get Away with Murder.

Honestly, Shonda Rhimes is a genius. How did she think of all of those stories?
This is what I know about Shonda Rhimes.
She loves a female main character that is Black and excellent in her field. She is committed to diversity in her casts, they are always multiracial. Rhimes stories have a level of plotting and machinations akin to thrillers.
But as the first season progressed and we met more of the characters, some new questions started to arise and I think that was meant that to be intentional.
Beyond wondering who the murderer was, I was thinking about race, class and black womanhood.
It made me question whose characters I felt were authentic, and why?
Some of my own assumptions made me feel uncomfortable.
Rhimes clearly knows how to build characters that we love, and in both How to Get Away with Murder and Grey’s Anatomy, explores the dynamics in large friendship groups.
I’m actually significantly less enamoured of the Keating Five than I was of the original five in Grey’s Anatomy season one. They’re too pampered, too rich, too pretty, too successful and clever for you to really care about them. Not like you were rooting for George, Izzy, Cristina, Meredith and Karev in Grey’s Anatomy. Their individual journeys and struggle was also in a highly competitive environment, but their characters made you like them and root for them. Whereas I have no feelings for any of the Keating Five, who bar Wes, seem to be kids that had pretty good lives. Maybe that’s what Rhimes is trying to explore?
And on the topic of Wes, who apparently went to community college and comes from an impoverished background and imo it doesn’t even feel authentic that he did.
Nate’s character could more authentically carry off being, “I’m from a poor background,” and I’m not sure why that is? Is it because he’s Black? Because he doesn’t have the pretty boy looks of Alfred Enoch?
No, it’s Nate’s character’s age, the look in his eyes and the way he carries his body. He has seen things, whereas Wes is a baby and innocent like the rest of the Keating Five even though he’s meant to have had a challenging background- he’s both poor and an orphan, right? But Wes has no edges!
Maybe I’m hypothesising that poverty gives an element of bodily difference for people- in the language they use, confidence overall and of feeling like you belong. I think the actor that plays Nate could convince us of that he had gone to community college more authentically, but is this because of my own internal racism? Or internal classism? Because to assume he could convince an audience more convincingly of being poor, and the question tumbling around in my head then is why? Is it purely because he is Black?

I was the first person in my family to go to a red-brick university, and I never have felt more out of place during that time, due to being Black, due to being working class, due to not being familiar with the countryside. I was massively homesick, felt alienated and isolated, but luckily I did make friends, so that feeling of alienation lessened overtime. However, I was still very aware that I was different to my friends due to having completely different upbringing.
When I went to university, I realised I’d read too many chick-lit novels where girls like me, they make the move, they find their people and they become a success. However, now I realise, while some of those novels were the rags-to-riches story archetype featuring women from a traditionally deprived socioeconomic background; the vast majority were women who were actually middle class. They were in a tricky time period of life, but already were in an industry like fashion or photography or publishing, which to get ahead in takes hard work and access to the right people.
15-year-old me, who had not yet learned about white privilege or intersectionality or class consciousness, didn’t realise that those books were not about women like me. Yes, we all might identify as women, but our journeys would not be the same.
So when Bonnie is warning Laurel away from Frank, who is Annalise’s, or should we say Anna-Mae’s hitman? Dogsbody? Security guard? Is it because she sincerely believes that Frank will get hurt, being Laurel’s ‘bit of rough’? I doubt it.
Speaking of Annalise, what I love about Annalise’s character is the veneer of strength she presents to the outside world and in the courtroom. She is bold and she is tenacious, and she loves to win in the way that people who have been denied success in the way they wanted it, has something to prove. She is also calculating and a morally grey character. I love how in the scene when she finds out about her husband’s betrayal, she wipes off her make-up and takes off her wig, revealing her natural hair underneath. Which, in this day and age is still a political statement, given how Black women’s hair and Black people’s hair, is policed.
In the sanctuary of her own bedroom, her own inner space, she reveals her underbelly, her naked, vulnerable self that cannot go back to unknown what she has seen. Any Black woman will be able to feel and see the significance of removing her wig, which represents her professional, more palatable to white society and to her profession self, to reveal the reality of who she is, a vulnerable Black woman who has been betrayed.
Likewise, that is why when her mother, played by Cicely Tyson, offers to brush her hair, Annalise, sitting in between her Mothers knees, we see her real self being comforted by her mother in a scene that most Black folk would recognise. I’m a child of the 80s, so that scene was me sitting in between my grandmother’s legs, her parting and oiling my hair with Luster’s pink oil moisturiser. The deft parting and detangling complete with a conk on the head with a brush when you’ve wriggled, and the all time favourite Caribbean statement would be uttered, “Do you want me to give you something to cry about?”.
All of this to say that Shonda Rhimes is a storyteller, par excellence. I am so invested to know who killed Lila that I’ve watched all 14 episodes of 15 episodes at a breakneck pace, and given that this TV show was created over 10 years ago, it shows that story still stands the test of time.
Maybe because some story archetypes last forever.



Comments