The rule breakers of the style world judgement pisses me off. Here's why. Part 2.
OR Why are the rule breakers so determined to tell the rest of us to break the rules?
In Part 1, I talked about why I get so frustrated with the idea that colour analysis somehow takes away women's autonomy.
Rules. Some people love them. Some people hate them.
I think comments and posts that say 'wear what you like' and 'colour analysis is a set of rules', underestimate how many women are looking for guidance. Some individuals overestimate how accessible information is.
We are oversaturated with information on what trends are in, and what we should and should not buy. The expectation is that women should innately know what to do or wear effortlessly - because we are somehow born with this knowledge?
What????
AND do not get me started on the pressure to look good.
This is a constant for women and starts from childhood.
'Don't wear that, wear this.'
'If you want to look nice, wear this.'
And this is the bit that I think the 'wear what you want' brigade misses:
The biggest methodological hurdle that the 'wear what you want' brigade has is that some actually enjoy having a palette/ guidelines to work with.
Arguably, having a framework helps with the mental overload many women carry as mothers/ carers/ as people who have spent decades of navigating the patriarchy.
Personally, having guidelines makes it easier for me to get dressed.
Knowing my style archetypes helps me to understand why some clothes, textures, fabrics feel right, and some make me feel like a costume.
It also explains why I love some looks on someone else, but would never wear these myself.
Others in my community agree on the point of guidelines:



I'm not rule breaker per se.
In fact dressing like a 'traditional' stylist would feel like a costume to me.
And this is where style archetypes and essences become relevant!
Style Archetypes and Essences
First, some key vocab:
Style Essences: John Kitchener posits seven distinct style essences based on your face shape and the vibe/ energy you give off. This is his unique system and relates to the types of clothes you wear and why, and includes your personality type.
Style Archetypes: Different visual styles related to how you dress and want others to perceive you. Also includes personality characteristics.
We all have a blend of several style essences/ archetypes, though some will be more predominant than others.
But what has that got to do with colour analysis and rule breaking, I hear you say????
Top row L-R, example of Classic, Natural, Creative, Gamine style archetypes (Gamine image from @gizemsvintagecloset)
Middle row L-R Ethereal/ Angelic, Street style, Romantic, Dramatic style archetypes
Bottom row - Descriptions of style archetypes and/ or personality essences
My key argument is that some of the style archetypes or style essences as personality types actually like, and thrive on breaking the style rules!
Whenever someone says, 'Oh, I don't care about the colour of things, I just wear what I like' or 'Ooh, I don't like the sound of colour analysis, it's too limiting and puts you in a box' I suspect that for many of them, one of their dominant style archetypes falls somewhere on the right of this graphic:

Why are the rule breakers so determined to tell the rest of us how to break the rules?
These are the more extroverted, experimental archetypes and so it makes sense they feel hemmed in with the specific rules.
And if you don't like rules, fine, don't use them!
Break all the fashion rules you want.
But recognise that there are women who feel more confident when they have some parameters to work with.
What works for you when you are getting dressed, does not necessarily work for me.
And that is fine.
Freedom in style doesn't have to look the same for everyone.
Let me know what you think below!
M x



Comments